Unveiling the Top Baits for Red Fish in Saint Augustine, FL: A Guide from Reel Spooled Charters

Mar 17, 2025

If you're passionate about fishing, you know the right bait can mean the difference between a great day and an empty cooler. In Saint Augustine, FL, a top spot for anglers, redfish are a prized target. Also known as red drum, these fish offer an exciting challenge. This guide will uncover the top baits and artificial lures that can maximize your chances of catching redfish in the stunning waters of Northeast Florida.

Understanding Redfish Behavior

To maximize your fishing success, it's crucial to understand redfish and their feeding habits. As opportunistic feeders, redfish thrive in diverse environments like estuaries and coastal waters. They mainly consume crustaceans, small baitfish, and various tiny organisms. For instance, studies show that over 60% of their diet consists of crabs and shrimp, making these the ideal choices for bait.

By selecting baits that closely resemble their natural diet, anglers can significantly boost their chances of a successful catch.

Live Baits for Redfish

Shrimp

Live shrimp stands out as one of the top choices for redfish bait. Their natural scent and movement attract hungry fish. Using live medium to large shrimp can yield impressive results.

When fishing with shrimp, opt for a light jig head or a popping cork to enhance the bait's presentation. A key tip is to keep the bait close to the bottom, where redfish typically forage for food. This method can significantly increase bites.

Close-up view of a live shrimp ready for fishing

Shrimp ready for redfish fishing

Pinfish

Pinfish also make for excellent redfish bait. Found in the same habitats as redfish, these lively fish draw attention effectively.

When using pinfish, hook them through the back to allow for natural swimming movements. This technique mimics their natural behavior, making them irresistible to hungry redfish.

Artificial Baits for Redfish

Soft Plastic Baits

Soft plastic baits have changed the game for targeting redfish. Available in numerous shapes, sizes, and colors, they allow anglers to tailor their approach based on fishing conditions.

Popular options include paddle tails and shrimp imitations. A weighted hook or jig head can aid in creating a natural presentation, enhancing your chances for a bite. For instance, using a 4-inch paddle tail in a bright color can increase visibility in murky waters.

Topwater Lures

Topwater lures are particularly effective when fishing in shallow waters, especially during early mornings and late afternoons. During these peak feeding times, redfish are more aggressive.

Lures such as popping plugs and walk-the-dog style designs mimic stress signals from baitfish, drawing redfish in. The thrill of watching a redfish strike a topwater lure makes this method especially rewarding.

High angle view of topwater lures arranged for fishing

Topwater lures ideal for catching redfish

Scented Baits

Scented baits like Fishbites have gained popularity due to their fish-attracting scents. These artificial baits are designed to draw redfish in, especially when they are less active and need a boost to bite.

Using Fishbites can increase success rates significantly; some anglers report catching up to 30% more fish when incorporating these baits into their strategy.

Fishbites Fish'n Strips Shrimp Longer Lasting Bait Fishing Lure | eBay

Strategies for Using Baits

Timing is Key

Successful redfishing in Saint Augustine hinges on timing. Early mornings and late afternoons are optimal feeding times.

Planning your fishing trips around these periods can enhance your likelihood of a good catch. Studies show that the best catch rates often occur within the first two hours of sunrise and the final hours before sunset.

Experimentation

Flexibility is crucial when fishing for redfish. Factors like water temperature, salinity, and weather can affect bait effectiveness.

Try different baits, colors, and presentation styles until you find the right combination for the day. For instance, if you’re not having success with shrimp, switch to a soft plastic or experiment with a topwater lure.

Fishing Techniques for Redfish

Bottom Fishing

Bottom fishing effectively targets redfish using heavier weights to keep bait close to the ocean floor. This method is especially productive with live shrimp or pinfish.

By keeping your bait in the strike zone, you can significantly increase your chances of enticing redfish to bite.

Drift Fishing

Drift fishing allows you to cover wider areas and locate actively feeding fish. It works well with artificial baits, particularly soft plastics.

As you let the current carry the bait, you can cast and create a presentation that redfish find hard to resist. Many anglers have found this technique increases their catch rate by as much as 40%.

Final Thoughts

Saint Augustine, FL, offers fantastic opportunities for redfish fishing. By understanding their feeding habits and choosing the right baits, such as live shrimp and pinfish or effective artificial options like soft plastics and topwater lures, your chances of success will improve significantly.

Whether you're out with a charter service like Reel Spooled Charters or enjoying a solo trip, proper bait choice and attentive techniques will maximize your time on the water.

With patience and practice, you'll experience the thrill of landing a beautiful redfish in one of Northeast Florida's most picturesque locations. Enjoy the adventure!

Eye-level view of scenic Saint Augustine waters

Scenic view of Saint Augustine waters for fishing


Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.